THE CONARD COURANT
Est. 1957
Luigi Mangione and the American Healthcare System
By Nora Elnemr
On December 4th, former UnitedHealthcare CEO, Brian Thompson, was shot and killed in New York City by Luigi Mangione. This event ultimately led to Mangione’s arrest. This incident sparked various reactions, with some expressing support for Mangione’s actions, while others condemned the murder.
The American healthcare system is a topic of significant debate, often criticized for its complexities and challenges. Some people argue that it denies coverage to many individuals, leading to financial hardships and untreated medical conditions. According to the US News & World Report, 18% of insured adults experienced a claim denial in the past 12 months. Additionally, only 28% of Americans rated U.S. healthcare coverage as excellent or good, with many expressing concerns about the quality and affordability of care. The Commonwealth Fund reported that 45% of insured, working-age adults faced unexpected medical bills or copayments in the past year, and nearly 40% of those who challenged their bills had them reduced or eliminated by their insurer.
UnitedHealthcare, being the largest insurer in the country, has received complaints about claim denials and customer service issues. In 2022, US News & World Report indicated that UnitedHealthcare denied nearly one-third of claims. While some critics argue that the system needs reform, others emphasize the importance of following regulations and maintaining financial sustainability.
Mangione's actions and the subsequent reactions have highlighted the deep frustrations some individuals feel toward the healthcare system. However, it is essential to recognize the impact of violence and the loss experienced by Brian Thompson’s family. Thompson was a father and husband, and his death has been a source of pain for his loved ones.
The case has also brought attention to Mangione's background and personal struggles. At 26, Mangione was an Ivy League graduate and a data scientist dealing with significant back pain. Friends and family were shocked by his actions, recalling him as a driven and successful individual. Mangione is currently facing multiple charges, including murder and terrorism, and his legal case continues to unfold.
Overall, this incident raises questions about the American healthcare system, personal responsibility, and the consequences of violence. It is essential to consider all perspectives and focus on finding constructive solutions to improve the system while respecting the lives and experiences of everyone involved.
​
Sources:
How Often Do Health Insurers Deny Patient Claims? | Healthiest Communities Health News | U.S. News
Nearly six in 10 CEOs fear losing their jobs: survey | HRD America
Denial of Care Based on Inability to Pay | Commonwealth Fund